Elements in Lit 201: Exceptions to the Rules

Filed in Elements in Lit , The Quirky Lover , Uncategorized Posted on February 15, 2012 @ 3:00 pm 7 comments

I’ve finally just finished reading Sarah MacLean’s Love by Numbers series with the last installment of Eleven Scandals to Start to Win a Duke’s Heart and I’ve discovered some recurring ideas, character, themes that bring the taste of life at that time to us, through historical romance novels.

The Regency Romance is made that much more appealing to its readers by the descriptions of the strict rules of society and of course, the main characters attempts to thumb their nose at said rules. With this in mind, I bring to you the top 6 exceptions to real Regency era rules. as portrayed in romance novels:

1- I’m bigger than you! We talked about the hierarchy of the British peerage before, but even if one character out ranks another, if they are smaller in demeanor and have done something to displease the hero of any tale, an intangible thing like rank won’t hold back a man on a mission if he has sheer size on his side. (And all of the heroes tend to be big, strong men, right?) In the end, the smaller man walks away from the challenge meekly, clearing the path for the large (and usually hopelessly in love by this point) hero.

2- My scandal is not anywhere near as bad as your scandal. Any character fearing scandal in “the ton” always seems to find someone that has bigger issues going on, in the public view. This is almost always the saving grace that allows our hero and heroine to get together in the end. In real life, people were probably shunned, sent to convents, or even imprisoned for bad behaviour, but somehow in fiction, the really bad ones (ie. those attempting to take liberties on weaker characters, the drunkards, the gamblers) meet an appropriate/ well deserved fate, where the ones falling under the category of simply having made a mistake (the young, unmarried lass getting herself ‘in the family way’, for example), find some form of redemption. This makes readers happy, knowing that good or bad, these characters get their just deserts.

3- The Dowager. Any woman offering her opinion was certainly frowned upon during a time when they were seen as second rate citizens, regardless of family ties. But a dowager, the mother of a nobleman who is usually just about to be ousted as Baroness or Duchess, etc., seems always able to take certain liberties without fear of reproach. This type of woman usually looks down on others in lower ranks from atop her stuck up nose, and perhaps even some that are considered scandalous (particularly in the dowager’s eyes) of a higher rank. Somehow this woman feels it is her duty to right the wrongs, as she sees it, of those that act out of turn. This is ironic, when it is her own blabber-mouthed ways that usually end up coming to bite her back in the end. Personally speaking, I can see a little of this attitude as being correct the older I get, when I feel “the younger generation” have no concept of the outside world. Perhaps it’s really true that you do get grumpy as you get older, which would be the fall back reason for the dowager’s outlook.

4- The Courtesan. It is also ironic that in many tales, the courtesan has an large amount of sway in the Regency society. This is a woman that sells herself for sex to the wealthiest men in the land. It is only her status as highly sought after by such men that allows people to look the other way, when in reality, she is not much better than the common prostitute (according to the fiction.) Of course, the women in contention for the men’s hearts (or wallets), do not see any difference with the courtesan, but a land ruled by men can easily be swayed by a little dirty pillow talk, right?

5- The Rake. The rake is the typical bachelor that prefers the unentangled courtesan’s company over taking a wife that would bore him to tears. This makes him much more sought after by the single woman of the ton, as his exploits are made legendary. And really? What woman wouldn’t take a challenge like this on, if she had any kind of spirit to her? Typically, the rakish noble (also known as a rogue, among many other sinfully fun names) is a handsome man, with plenty of land, a title, and all things a woman should be looking for in a mate. His only real downfall is his status, but in the end, there’s always one female out there that is able to tame him. *sigh*

6- The Wallflower. My favourite of the stereotypical characters in Regency Romance. The wallflower is a lady that is usually not the petite woman that is sought after by the eligible bachelors or is too shy to have anyone take notice. She would be found at a ball, hiding in a corner, very possibly with a book in her hand. (That’s right folks, consider me a wallflower 😉 ) But she has some hidden qualities that will bring her to the attention of the hero in question, whether it’s her challenge to the man in one form or other, or her quick wit and intelligence (thanks to all those books she’s been reading). In the end, the wallflower becomes the belle of all balls from then on out.

Do these stereotypes sound about right? Are there any other characters in Regency Romances that deserve a spot on this list? What are some of your favourite books that feature these people?

And one last question that I put forth to you: Which character would you be in a historical romance? I’m still relatively new to this genre, but these have been my initial observations so far. I am looking forward to all of your thoughts 🙂

About Jackie

Jackie is a quirky mom, living in Ontario, Canada. She's a bookkeeper by day and a book lover by night. She also blogs at The Novel Nation and writes occasionally for Heroes and Heartbreakers.

Share This Post

Subscribe and stay up-to-date

Via E-Mail:

Follow us via RSS, twitter and facebook:


Join the Discussion
  • pattepoilue February 16, 2012 at 6:59 am

    LOL that sounds about right! Sadly I think I’d be the Wallflower =P

    I adore Dowager characters in Historical romances most of the time they are just hilarious. Like in Julia Quinn’s books and Sabrina Jeffries Hellion series.

    It’s just WAY too hard to choose only a few books to mention. The last one I adore had the typical Scarred and tortured hero *swoooooooooon* (She Tempts the Duke) I like it even more than the rake figure. *happy sigh*

    • Jackie February 16, 2012 at 10:50 am

      I think the Dowagers are always feisty and fun, too. And, I think it’s good to be a wallflower initially. They always end up with the best men in these books 😉

      I have so much to catch up on in historical romances, but I’ll have to check out the ones you mentioned.

  • Rebs @ Book Rants February 16, 2012 at 10:28 am

    What about “The Wife” as a common recurring theme. So many HR books have a arranged marriage and the husband and wife are not in love. Some reason or another the husband or wife decide they must woo the other

    • Jackie February 16, 2012 at 11:11 am

      That’s very true! The arranged marriage was a big concern for those girls dreaming of one day achieving the “love match” that was not the norm, if you’re to believe what’s written. Thanks 🙂

  • Cristina C. February 16, 2012 at 1:05 pm

    I love the list. My suggestions can sometimes go along with the Wallflower. The Innocent knows nothing but, he get’s her into bed and some how she’s ready for anything. Then there’s a theme I’ve seen a lot lately of Just the Sex. Where she just want’s learn about sex but, he’s very much into changing her opinion on that. 🙂

  • aurian February 16, 2012 at 2:49 pm

    Good list Jackie, but I think you should add the friend/confidante/maid to the list. Most heroines have a good relationship with their personal maids, and don’t look down on servants, which makes them more likeable, because face it, we readers would be the working class in those times 😉
    If you like Wallflowers, I really need to recommend Lisa Kleypass Wallflower books to you 🙂 The one with the seasons in the titles.

  • Tamsyn February 18, 2012 at 5:06 am

    I would add the Governess. She would make a great heroine, falling in love with the children’s father or uncle.
    As for the character in a historical romance, I would pick the Wallflower. Sort of suits me in real life too. :o)

Previous Post
Next Post
Luvo designed by Internet Marketing In conjunction with Template Wordpress , R4 DS , Best SUV.